• Home
  • About
  • Shop
  • Sign Up For My Newsletter
  • Contact

Parenting From The Heart

Empowering parents to teach their children with positive discipline

  • Pregnancy & Babies
  • Parenting Toddlers
  • Young Children
  • Tweens and Beyond
  • Education
You are here: Home / Positive Parenting Strategies / How to discipline a child: Why scientists say this is the best approach
How to discipline a child: Why scientists say this is the best approach

January 14, 2019 By Alana Pace 23 Comments

How to discipline a child: Why scientists say this is the best approach

How to discipline a child effectively? So often, our children don’t listen, they act out, or don’t behave the way we have taught them. Inside you will read the most effective approach on how to use positive parenting to discipline a child.

Get a printable with tips on being a calmer parent at the bottom of this post.


As parents, we have an internal desire to give children more opportunity, richer experiences, and a better upbringing than we had. Part of that involves avoiding our parents’ mistakes and parenting our kids to the best of our abilities. Despite the best of intentions, the way we were raised largely acts as the foundation from which we parent.

This means that if we were raised with threats of being spanked, constantly lectured, or sent into timeouts when we misbehaved, chances are, at some point, we will use the same tactics with our own kids.

Related reading: Time In vs. Timeout and the Fundamental Mistake you Want to Avoid

For example, if I’m not mindful, I catch myself lecturing my kids.

I find it happens when I’m tired, desperately trying to just get the house cleaned up, or an assignment finished for school.

My kids sense my preoccupation.

girl playing with her brother nearby here is how to effective discipline a child

My daughter will have an elaborate play scene set up including a makeshift restaurant, a pool, and a hotel. All of the food will be organized in rows. She will have tables made out of small boxes, grocery baskets, and little menus. That’s when her little brother decides this is his chance to move in beside my daughter. He always seems to get just a little too close.

She states she needs space.

My son takes this declaration as an invitation to annoy her more.

The frustration that has been brewing in my daughter for minutes boils over. She pushes my son away.

That’s when I snap out of the get-‘er-done trance I’m in. But because I’m still somewhat focused on finishing the task at hand, I do not parent mindfully. Instead, I default to lecturing.

“Keep your hands to yourself! You should know better.”

Or, “She said she wanted space. LEAVE HER ALONE!”

I tend to catch myself saying one of the two more than I’d care to admit.

Related reading: Put a stop to sibling rivalry using unbelievably simple strategies

This is the problem with this approach.

Lecturing doesn’t work all that well. When I scold my children, their brains are in a reactive state. For my daughter, she has just had her brother encroach on her territory. And his trespassing has put her into a fight mode. She pushes her brother because she is in a state of hyperarousal. Then, I come in and talk to her in a stern tone further underscoring her feelings of threat.

My son feels rejected because his sister won’t play with him. And, he feels threatened because his sister just pushed him. Then, I come in and scold him reinforcing his mental state of fight, flight or freeze.

Neurologically, neither child is in a state where he or she can listen to what I am saying. Epinephrine (adrenalin), norepinephrine (noradrenaline) and cortisol (the stress hormone) are present in their brains impacting their ability to listen. Even if they weren’t in a state of hyperarousal, my children are strong-willed at the best of times and don’t respond well to authoritarian parenting.

Related download: {FREE} Guide to Positive Discipline With Printable Cheatsheets

How to discipline a child effectively

In order to help our children understand and embody our values, we must scaffold them from a reactive to a receptive state. This means we need to connect with our children. According to Dr Daniel Seigel, clinical professor of psychiatry, what moves anyone from a reactive to a receptive state are feelings of:

  • love,
  • kindness,
  • compassion,
  • empathy, and
  • connectedness.

Once a child is calm, he or she is in a receptive state to be disciplined. To learn more about reactive versus responsive states, check out this video from Dr Siegel below.

The three-step approach for how to discipline a child

First, it is important to distinguish between the two meanings of discipline. The first is to code behaviour by use of punishment. The second, according to Merriam-Webster’s dictionary, is to correct or train the mental or moral faculties.

We understand that the former approach puts a child into a state where she feels threatened, fearful or frozen. The latter creates a situation where the child is likely to listen and behave in the future.

Related reading: What is Positive Discipline and Why You Might Have it Wrong

Here is how.

According to Daniel Siegel, MD and Tina Payne Bryson, PhD, answering these three questions will help ensure you are parenting in a way that promotes calmness and encourages listening, aka a receptive state. When you’re about to discipline your child, ask:

1. Why did my child act this way?

Was she tired, overstimulated, and/or lacking the word to express her feelings? Did she feel like she needed me and I wasn’t available? Is she scared, insecure, or worried? Does she feel threatened? Has my child been getting enough attention from me?

2. What do I want to teach at this moment?

Is it calmness, sharing, or for him to use his words? Do I want him to learn patience, selflessness, kindness, or compassion? Establish what you want to teach before proceeding.

3. What is the best way to teach this lesson?

As mentioned above, it is not best to teach a child when he is in a reactive state. For instance, I have tried to tell my son he’s okay when he’s had a full-blown meltdown.

It does not work.

The best approach, in my experience, is to wait for calmness and then engage in a dialogue about what happened. My daughter is the most open to having hard discussions when we’re in the car one-on-one, snuggling before bedtime or while colouring. My son is better right after he’s let out all of his feelings. Sometimes, this means going into his bedroom with him and waiting quite a while for him to regain composure. Only when he’s calm and is ready to engage with me, then we talk.

Related reading: Why you shouldn’t punish tantrums and what to do instead

How to discipline a child – barriers to success

While this approach is a simple and effective way to discipline a child, it is not easy. In fact, if you’re new to this approach, it will feel foreign. And, there will be times where you don’t perfectly execute it.

Read more about why it’s completely normal to fail as a parent here.

Understand like all new behaviours, it will take a while before these three questions become habitual. In fact, the authors of No Drama Discipline suggest it might be helpful to copy out the three questions and put them on post-it notes. Then, place the notes around your home and in the car as reminders.

Aside from remembering how to discipline a child, there will be other barriers to success like:

  • Fatigue,
  • Not enough self-care,
  • Perceived scrutiny of others – maybe there are people in your life that feel that if you aren’t scolding your child, you aren’t teaching her.
  • Lack of support.

If you can brainstorm your barriers to success and create a plan, this approach will be much easier to implement.

Conclusion

Becoming a more mindful parent is a process. There are times we will default to mistakes of our past. However, the more we practice, the better we will get at promoting a receptive mindset where our kids want to listen.

For additional reading on this approach, I highly recommend reading the following books:


Sign up to get your free printable

Get a printable with tips for being calmer and more mindful when you subscribe.

Put in your name and email. Then click the button below.

Send me this printable.

We won’t send you spam. Unsubscribe at any time.

Powered By ConvertKit

More great articles you might find helpful

Research says this is how to execute positive parenting from a position of strength

Why punishment is ineffective and what to do instead

What is positive discipline and why you might have it wrong 

Why authoritative parenting is essential now but may not have been before

Filed Under: Parenting Toddlers, Parenting Tweens and Beyond, Parenting Young Children, Positive Parenting Strategies, Posts, Readers' Favourites Tagged With: blog, developmental psychology, Life Lessons, motherhood, Parenting, parenting from the heart, positive discipline, positive parenting

Subscribe to get the latest

free goodies straight to your inbox

Previous Post: « Parenting a Strong-Willed Child: 10 surefire tips for effective discipline
Next Post: How to Stop Sibling Rivalry Using Unbelievably Simple Strategies »

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Jess says

    February 18, 2020 at 9:44 pm

    How to discipline a soft spoken, sensitive, nearly 4 yr old little girl when she screams at and hits her 18 month old brother without preaching, timeouts, shaming?

    Reply
  2. Ayana says

    July 16, 2020 at 12:15 am

    Very beneficial

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Primary Sidebar


Hi! I'm Alana. When I'm not nursing cold, stale coffee, I usually can be found with the baby on my hip, barefoot, and racing after my two older kids. Thanks to a degree in psychology and a free-range childhood backing onto an expansive evergreen forest, positive parenting and play-based learning are my passions. Read more here.

Stay up to date

Join me on Instagram

parentfromheart

Alana-Parenting From The Heart
I’m going to have to agree with this one via @ I’m going to have to agree with this one 

via @thatgirl409
It’s so rare I get a photo with all three of my It’s so rare I get a photo with all three of my babes and even still it isn’t picture perfect but I’ll take it.

When I scroll through my phone and look at my Facebook memories I realize that probably 99% of the time it’s me taking the picture, and it isn’t a selfie.

So here’s to both making more memories with all my kiddos and taking more photos of us together.

#motherhood #childhoodunplugged #goplayoutside #westcoast #sechelt
I had a friend reach out about promoting about a v I had a friend reach out about promoting about a very important cause.

Here is the info he sent me and how you can help out:

Babies born premature or critically ill need our help more than ever. @SandraSchmirler Foundation Telethon goes TODAY on TSN sandraschmirler.org or 866-210-6011 to donate. Share this post to your stories or tweet the hashtag #ChampionsStartSmall to get word out ❤️🙏
#socialdistancingchristmas we met my brother downt #socialdistancingchristmas we met my brother downtown at a park, he lined my kids up like they were in front of a firing squad and presented them their gifts 🤣

#covid19 #socialdistancing #chritsmas #yaletown #YVR
Getting our tree. So nice to get outside of the ho Getting our tree. So nice to get outside of the house to do something aside from getting groceries or bringing the kids to school 

#socialdistancing #christmas2020 

#mostwonderfultimeoftheyear #Christmastree
One of our favourite pastimes 😍 #sechelt #rock One of our favourite pastimes 😍

#sechelt #rocks #sunshinecoast #beautifulBC #goplayoutside #childhoodunplugged #parentingfromtheheart
On my facebook page, this weekend, I posted an ima On my facebook page, this weekend, I posted an image of Kamala Harris with her quote, "While I may be the first woman in this office, I will not be the last, because every little girl watching tonight sees that this is a country of possibilities." The intent was to honour the first female to be the projected vice president in the United States.

It evoked a slew of opposing opinions, backlash and emotion. 

I received several comments that I should stick to parenting and not post political content on my page. So I wanted to make something clear. 

Parenting is political. 

Many of the articles on this page are based on how to raise children who embody the parents' values. Our values are reflected in policy and politics throughout all of our countries.

The majority of this page centres on are the rights of children to live in peaceful, respectful homes where discipline is to teach and not to hit or hurt them.

The content of this page also reflects equitable education and the developmentally appropriate treatment of children.

I believe in celebrating childhood. 

From time-to-time page also focuses on the wellbeing of marginalized groups because children deserve to see their race,  gender, and sexual orientation represented and protected in the world. Equally, each child should feel their parents have a respected place in society regardless of their skin colour, sexual orientation, country of origin, or marital status.

All of that said, this page welcomes competing ideas and differing belief systems. I am of the firm belief that liberal and conservative beliefs are important and deserve representation. 

If you aren't comfortable with this stance, you are welcome to unfollow. 

If you'd like to stay, thank you.
-Continued in comments-
Hotel pool ready. 🤣🤣🤣 #forky #accessorie Hotel pool ready. 🤣🤣🤣

#forky #accessoriesoftheday #lovehim
Love this ❤️ Love this ❤️
Load More… Follow on Instagram

Footer

Privacy policy

Terms | Conditions | Privacy Policy

Let’s Connect

  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Google+
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
  • Twitter

Looking for something?

Copyright © 2021 · Market Theme On Genesis Framework · WordPress · Infinus

13205shares
  • 12530
We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you continue to use this site we will assume that you are happy with it.OkRead more