• Home
  • About
  • Shop
  • Sign Up For My Newsletter
  • Contact

Parenting From The Heart

a place for parents who aren't perfect but are trying their best

  • Pregnancy & Babies
  • Parenting Toddlers
  • Young Children
  • Tweens and Beyond
  • Education
You are here: Home / Positive Parenting Strategies / Parenting Babies / “It Takes a Village:” 3 anthropological reasons mothers need a community of support
“It Takes a Village:” 3 anthropological reasons mothers need a community of support

January 13, 2022 By Alana Pace 5 Comments

“It Takes a Village:” 3 anthropological reasons mothers need a community of support

Her “Have a great day,” was like a slap in the face.

I was scrambling to find a way to continue our conversation and yet I knew her cheery salutation was the cue for me to leave.

Dejected, I packed my groceries into my double-wide stroller and left the store. As I let my oldest out of her seat and grabbed her chubby pink hand, I took a deep breath.

I needed a minute; I barely recognized myself.

Somewhere between my wedding day and back-to-back pregnancies my friends seemingly disappeared. 

Maybe it was that it was too much to participate in all of the wedding events followed so closely by a baby shower.

Maybe it was because I hadn’t reached out enough. 

Or maybe it was just that I’d found myself in a place where we could no longer relate to one another. Their lives remained relatively the same while mine was punctuated by nap schedules and tandem nursing.

I was barely holding it all together.

My apartment was in a perpetual state of disarray. The carpet was stained from baby puke mixing with industrial-strength cleaner. Piles of laundry occupied the couch and dining table. All the while, Fisher-Price people pilgrimaged across our home. To top it all off, my youngest was almost a year old and hadn’t yet slept through the night once.

And so the reality was my life had been reduced to trying to stay afloat while clambering for conversation from cashiers.

Read: The Lonely Mom: How to Conquer Feelings of Loneliness

It wasn’t until years later that I realized that it wasn’t supposed to be this way.

While gathering research for a paper on culture and infant development, it became clear that the support we offer mothers is wildly insufficient.

Western cultures, especially North American ones, expect families to be nuclear and mothers autonomous (1). Our culture expects two adults take care of their own family while having successful careers and focusing on self-improvement, but this isn’t realistic or reasonable.

It takes a village to raise a child isn’t just a warm sentiment but a requisite for raising children for a number of important reasons.

1. Infants are born prematurely when compared to other animals.

Because of their large neocortex, infants are born underdeveloped and highly dependent on their caregivers (1, 2, 3). In contrast, many mammals can walk shortly after birth (6). Also, non-human primates can cling to their mothers’ backs to stay in close proximity. However, our young must be carried or worn for their first year and even longer!

2. We raise our young past the age they are weaned.

Generally speaking, other mammals raise offspring until they are weaned. Then their young are either on their own or become part of the greater pack, pride, or pod. (Of course, there is the occasional bear who may have a yearling while still caring for her new cubs. But this is not the norm.) After weaning, human children need highly engaged care from toddlerhood on. It isn’t until adulthood that children have reached nutritional independence. And even then, in most countries, adult children live close to home.

3. Humans are the only species that raise multiple dependents, of different ages concurrently.

However, it’s common for humans to have several children at various ages and at relatively short birth intervals (1, 3). (I have a four-year-old, an eight-year-old, and a nine-year-old.) In comparison and as mentioned above, mammals wean their young and then send them on their way!

Read: These Research-Backed Strategies Will Make you Happier

Because of this, humans are meant to be communal breeders.

Non-parent caregivers ease the workload of mothers so that they can split their finite time between contributing to and caring for their families. This is seen cross-culturally. In the Congo, Efe people share in carrying infants by transferring their babies to different caregivers several times each hour (2). Women can’t forage, nurse their babies, and keep them soothed without help. Infants in this culture are in nearly constant physical contact with someone. Children in The Gambia are taken care of by older childer and other adults (4). And in western countries, children often attend daycare, school, and receive care from grandparents (6).

Sadly, in western countries “the village” is becoming less available unless it’s paid for.

Despite there being many developmental benefits to having kin-based childcare, it is becoming increasingly rare. Hardy (2009) states that modernization is negatively correlated with proximity to and care from extended family (1). In short, whether intentional or not, we tend to choose opportunities for self-advancement over accepting and offering support.

The problem remains that mothers always meet children’s needs for food, stimulation, safety and security without help.

As such, the support from grandparents, extended family, and friends has largely been replaced by paid childcare. And though paid childcare most certainly plays a crucial role in our lives, not everyone can afford it and it isn’t enough.

Read: The worst advice for new moms made right!

The more I read about cultural norms in other societies, the more I realized we should be doing better.

As I continued on with my research, I learned just how natural it is in other societies to rally around new mothers and provide them ongoing help. For instance, Tronick, Morelli, and Winn found that Efe infants had an average of 14 non-maternal caregivers in their first 18 months of life (5). These infants were still largely attended to by their mothers when upset or hungry. However, the mothers in this population literally had their village to help them raise their babies.

This stood in stark contrast to my experience as a new mom desperate for a cashier to want to talk to me.

Looking back, I cannot make my own experience better but I can and will do better for other new moms.

For more great reads like this, try:

These Research-Backed Strategies Will Make You a Happier Parent
The worst advice for new moms made right!
The Lonely Mom: How to Conquer This Feeling and Engage a Village Again
This is why positive parenting is essential now

Filed Under: Parenting Babies, Positive Parenting Strategies, Posts Tagged With: motherhood, new mom, newborn, Parenting, parenting from the heart

Subscribe to get the latest

free goodies straight to your inbox

Previous Post: « How to respond when your child hates school
Next Post: How to discipline a child: Why replacing harsh punishments with compassion will improve behaviour »

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Primary Sidebar


Hi! I'm Alana. When I'm not nursing cold, stale coffee, I usually can be found with the baby on my hip, barefoot, and racing after my two older kids. Thanks to a degree in psychology and a free-range childhood backing onto an expansive evergreen forest, positive parenting and play-based learning are my passions. Read more here.

Stay up to date

Join me on Instagram

parentfromheart

Alana-Parenting From The Heart
Me to my 5yo: stay still I want to take your pictu Me to my 5yo: stay still I want to take your picture.
My 5yo:
A beautiful reminder to find little ways to connec A beautiful reminder to find little ways to connect with our children ❤️❤️❤️
Often people fear responsive parenting will create Often people fear responsive parenting will create needy kids. 

Developmental research suggests otherwise. 

The more reliably and compassionately that we respond to our children’s needs, the more secure and assured they feel to venture out into the world.

Attachment & independence aren’t two opposite sides of a spectrum but two sides of the same coin.
😍Yep - Absolutely love this. via @Angela Anagno 😍Yep - Absolutely love this.
via @Angela Anagnost-Repke, Writer
Every. single. time I see this I laugh out loud 🤣🤣🤣
I can't think of anything more true.
via https://twitter.com/amydillon
Yes 👏👏👏 via @DissociativeDiaries Yes 👏👏👏
via @DissociativeDiaries
Every. Day. Via Matt Beaudreau Every. Day.

Via Matt Beaudreau
I remember in my earlier days of parenting when I I remember in my earlier days of parenting when I had two under two so much of my life was spent thinking I’ll be happy when…

I’ll be happy when they sleep through the night.

I’ll be happy when my husband doesn’t have to work such late hours.

I’ll be happy when I look and feel like myself again and not a feeding troth 😬😬😬

As it turns out this struggle with finding happiness isn’t unique to me or parenting. 

Collectively our mental health is suffering, but there are many research backed ways to improve happiness. (Link in bio to read more).
♥️♥️ via Heather Shumaker ♥️♥️

via Heather Shumaker
THIS. 🙌🙌 (Follow Maryfairy Boberry) THIS. 🙌🙌 (Follow Maryfairy Boberry)
👣 via @creativechildmag 👣

via @creativechildmag
via Happy as a Mother 🙂❤ via Happy as a Mother 🙂❤
Though there are countless people who understand t Though there are countless people who understand the importance of positive, responsive parenting, the idea that young children should self-soothe remains a prevalent belief.

Though this ideology is well-intentioned, it actually goes against what we know about human development.

Babies come into the world highly dependent on responsive caregiving not only for nurturance and protection but also to foster social and emotional development.

While it may seem that leaving a child to cry will help her learn to cope, it actually floods her brain with cortisol. She doesn’t learn to self-soothe but instead to shut down.

Though it may seem counterintuitive to some, independence is fostered through responsive care. The less stressed a child feels, the safer he feels to explore his world. The less stressed he feels, the more appropriate his emotional responses become.

This is first seen in late infancy but pervades through childhood and adulthood.

Have any questions about these findings? Feel free to comment below or send me a message!
❤️❤️❤️❤️ Teach Through Love ❤️❤️❤️❤️ Teach Through Love
via @unconditional_parenting. via @unconditional_parenting.
via The Outnumbered Mother via The Outnumbered Mother
❤❤❤ ❤❤❤
😂 😂
So often independence and attachment are thought t So often independence and attachment are thought to be mutually exclusive.
However, research shows that in order for children (and adults) to be independent, they need to feel safe and secure within their closest relationships. In childhood, this means having caregivers who respond to distress and both emotional and physical needs.
In adulthood, people who have responsive and caring partners feel more stable and comfortable being independent.
So hold and comfort those babies.
Hug and respond to your kids.
Love and hold space for the adults you are closest to.
Attachment fosters independence.
Absolutely this. Via Living FULL Absolutely this. Via Living FULL
Load More… Follow on Instagram

Footer

Privacy policy

Terms | Conditions | Privacy Policy

Let’s Connect

  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
  • Twitter

Looking for something?

Copyright © 2023 · Market Theme On Genesis Framework · WordPress · Infinus

3 shares